The studies above are genuinely cross-cultural, but most of them aren't diaspora-centred, Uganda and the Aka are continental African fieldwork, not the Black and Caribbean diasporic experience most of our families are actually living. This is the literature that is, foundational studies alongside work as recent as 2024.
Othermothering
Community mothering as a named, structured caregiving system: not an absence of structure
Patricia Hill Collins' concept of "othermothers" describes a recognised system within Black communities, particularly in the US, where women who aren't a child's biological mother, grandmothers, aunts, neighbours, church elders, take on real, expected responsibility for childrearing. It's documented as a deliberate, functional practice, not a deficit version of the nuclear family.
Hill Collins, Black Feminist Thought (1990, rev. 2000)
Kinship Networks
Extended kin exchange networks as adaptive, resilient family structure
Carol Stack's ethnographic study of an African American community found dynamic, highly structured kinship-exchange networks, child-rearing, resources, and support flowing across households, not confined to a single nuclear unit. It directly challenged the "unstable Black family" narrative dominant in policy research at the time, documenting resilience where deficit was assumed.
Stack, All Our Kin (1974)
Matrifocal Caribbean Families
Caribbean family structures organised around mothers and extended female kin are a documented, functional norm
Edith Clarke's foundational study of Jamaican family life documented matrifocal households, often multigenerational, often without a resident father, as a coherent, long-standing family form in the Caribbean, not a broken version of a nuclear ideal. This structure persists among Caribbean diasporic families well after migration.
Clarke, My Mother Who Fathered Me (1957)
Caribbean Diaspora, Updated
Caribbean alloparenting adapts to migration rather than breaking down under it
A 2020 review in the Annual Review of Anthropology examined Black Caribbean communities living in the UK, US, and Canada, arguing that caregiving in these families routinely extends well beyond one household, shaped by, not undermined by, transnational labour migration. It challenges research models built around a single bounded household as poorly suited to how the majority of the world's families actually organise care.
Nelson, Beyond the Household: Caribbean Families and Biocultural Models of Alloparenting, Annual Review of Anthropology (2020)
Clinical Terminology
"Fictive kin" and "othermothers" are established terms in Black nursing and clinical scholarship
A 2014 paper in the Journal of the National Black Nurses' Association argues clinical intake and case documentation need a "culturally appropriate pedigree nomenclature" that recognises fictive kin and othermothers as real caregiving roles, not an informal workaround to be translated into standard family-tree categories that don't fit.
Spruill, Coleman, Powell-Young, Williams & Magwood, Journal of the National Black Nurses' Association (2014)